Jump to content
Toggle menu
Toggle preferences menu
Toggle personal menu
Not logged in
Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits.

Topics and lesson plans: Difference between revisions

From Sense & Sensibility & Science
// Edit via Wikitext Extension for VSCode
No edit summary
 
(27 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
All the lesson plans used in the full fourteen week version of the course that's run at UC Berkeley. These include lecture videos as well detailed content that can be used in smaller discussion sections.
Clicking on the topics takes you to the lesson plans. These are listed in the order that they're typically taught. A high-level conceptual organization scheme for these lessons can be found on the [[Concept groupings|concept groupings]] page. For more on how to shape these into your schedule see the page on [[Designing your schedule|designing your schedule]].
<!-- These include lecture videos as well detailed content that can be used in smaller discussion sections.. -->


{| class="wikitable"
{{Lesson table}}
|[[1.1 Introduction and When Is Science Relevant]]
|When is science relevant? The many uses of a scientific approach.
|-
|[[1.2 Shared Reality and Modeling]]
|Science is grounded in belief in a common, shared reality with some degree of regularity.
|-
|[[2.1 Senses and Instrumentation]]
|Science uses both our direct senses and a variety of instruments to extend our ability to observe phenomena. We trust our instruments for the same reasons we trust our senses; interactive exploration and comparison.
|-
|[[2.2 Systematic and Statistical Uncertainty]]
|This topic explores the sources of error and uncertainty in data.
|-
|[[3.1 Probabilistic Reasoning]]
|Using meta-judgments of the likelihood that your best judgment is right— how confident you are—enables decisions that take uncertainty into account.
|-
|[[3.2 Calibration of Credence Levels]]
|It is important to check the calibration of credence levels; that is, how good one's judgments are about how likely each of one's claims is to be right.
|-
|[[4.1 Signal and Noise]]
|The challenges of finding the information we want amidst messy data.
|-
|[[4.2 Finding Patterns in Random Noise]]
|We often find mistake noise for signal; how do we minimize these mistakes, given that they are not always easy to tell apart?
|-
|[[5.1 False Positives and Negatives]]
|Considering the relative costs of each possible mistake helps us make better decisions under conditions of uncertainty, when we cannot eliminate the possibility of a mistake either way.
|-
|[[5.2 Scientific Optimism]]
|Without scientific optimism, the idea that science is necessarily iterative and if we as scientists keep looking we will eventually gain insights, scientists would have discovered far less than they have.
|-
|[[6.1 Correlation and Causation]]
|An introduction to the scientific approach to determining causal relationships.
|-
|[[6.2 Hill's Criteria]]
|Building on Correlation and Causation, we examine how to collect evidence for causality in more difficult cases.
|-
|[[7.1 Causation, Blame, and Policy]]
|Distinguishing singular causation (A caused B) from general causation (X tends to cause Y).
|-
|[[7.2 Emergent Phenomena]]
|Many phenomena in science are emergent, i.e., visible only at higher levels of organization. This tends to occur when large numbers of elements interact, e.g. as in individuals on social media.
|-
|[[8.1 Orders of Understanding]]
|Because each event and/or phenomenon has many causal factors, it is often important to distinguish which factors affect it the most and which factors play a smaller role.
|-
|[[8.2 Fermi Problems]]
|Estimating quantities based on what we know.
|-
|[[9.1 Heuristics]]
|Some of the heuristics biases that make our probability judgments go awry.
|-
|[[9.2 Biases]]
|Some of the psychological biases that make our probability judgments go awry.
|-
|[[10.1 Confirmation Bias]]
|Our tendency to preserve our existing or preferred beliefs, even against the evidence.
|-
|[[10.2 Blinding]]
|Blind analysis, the practice of deciding how we will analyze data before finding out if the analysis we have chosen supports our hypothesis, counteracts confirmation bias.
|-
|[[11.1 Pathological Science]]
|How to catch bad science.
|-
|[[11.2 When Is Science Suspect]]
|The capacity for science to be misused to reinforce existing power structures.
|-
|[[12.1 Wisdom of Crowds and Herd Thinking]]
|Explore ways that groups fall short of their optimal reasoning ability. There are better and worse ways to aggregate a group's knowledge.
|-
|[[12.2 Grill the Guest]]
|Confront a working scientist about their work using course concepts.
|-
|[[13.1 Denver Bullet Study]]
|The Denver Bullet Study offers one approach to integrating facts and values in a controversial real-world problem, drawing facts from a set of experts, gauging the values of different stakeholders, and bringing these together for a final decision.
|-
|[[13.2 Deliberative Polling]]
|Another approach to getting groups of people to come together to make decisions, in a process where the integration of facts and values is scaffolded.
|-
|[[14.1 Scenario Planning|14.1 Scenario Planning]]
|A third approach to integrating facts and values under conditions of uncertainty about what the future will be like.
|-
|[[14.2 Wrap Up|14.2 Wrap Up]]
|An overview and conclusion of the course.
|}
<!-- {| class="wikitable"
![[1.1 Introduction and When Is Science Relevant]]
!When is science relevant? The many uses of a scientific approach.
|-
![[1.2 Shared Reality and Modeling]]
!Science is grounded in belief in a common, shared reality with some degree of regularity.
|-
![[2.1 Senses and Instrumentation]]
!Science uses both our direct senses and a variety of instruments to extend our ability to observe phenomena. We trust our instruments for the same reasons we trust our senses; interactive exploration and comparison.
|-
![[2.2 Systematic and Statistical Uncertainty]]
!This topic explores the sources of error and uncertainty in data.
|-
![[3.1 Probabilistic Reasoning]]
!Using meta-judgments of the likelihood that your best judgment is right— how confident you are—enables decisions that take uncertainty into account.
|-
![[3.2 Calibration of Credence Levels]]
!It is important to check the calibration of credence levels; that is, how good one's judgments are about how likely each of one's claims is to be right.
|-
![[4.1 Signal and Noise]]
!The challenges of finding the information we want amidst messy data.
|-
![[4.2 Finding Patterns in Random Noise]]
!We often find mistake noise for signal; how do we minimize these mistakes, given that they are not always easy to tell apart?
|-
![[5.1 False Positives and Negatives]]
!Considering the relative costs of each possible mistake helps us make better decisions under conditions of uncertainty, when we cannot eliminate the possibility of a mistake either way.
|-
![[5.2 Scientific Optimism]]
!Without scientific optimism, the idea that science is necessarily iterative and if we as scientists keep looking we will eventually gain insights, scientists would have discovered far less than they have.
|-
![[6.1 Correlation and Causation]]
!An introduction to the scientific approach to determining causal relationships.
|-
![[6.2 Hill's Criteria]]
!Building on Correlation and Causation, we examine how to collect evidence for causality in more difficult cases.
|-
![[7.1 Causation, Blame, and Policy]]
!Distinguishing singular causation (A caused B) from general causation (X tends to cause Y).
|-
![[7.2 Emergent Phenomena]]
!Many phenomena in science are emergent, i.e., visible only at higher levels of organization. This tends to occur when large numbers of elements interact, e.g. as in individuals on social media.
|-
![[8.1 Orders of Understanding]]
!Because each event and/or phenomenon has many causal factors, it is often important to distinguish which factors affect it the most and which factors play a smaller role.
|-
![[8.2 Fermi Problems]]
!Estimating quantities based on what we know.
|-
![[9.1 Heuristics]]
!Some of the heuristics biases that make our probability judgments go awry.
|-
![[9.2 Biases]]
!Some of the psychological biases that make our probability judgments go awry.
|-
![[10.1 Confirmation Bias]]
!Our tendency to preserve our existing or preferred beliefs, even against the evidence.
|-
![[10.2 Blinding]]
!Blind analysis, the practice of deciding how we will analyze data before finding out if the analysis we have chosen supports our hypothesis, counteracts confirmation bias.
|-
![[11.1 Pathological Science]]
!How to catch bad science.
|-
![[11.2 When Is Science Suspect]]
!The capacity for science to be misused to reinforce existing power structures.
|-
![[12.1 Wisdom of Crowds and Herd Thinking]]
!Explore ways that groups fall short of their optimal reasoning ability. There are better and worse ways to aggregate a group's knowledge.
|-
![[12.2 Grill the Guest]]
!Confront a working scientist about their work using course concepts.
|-
![[13.1 Denver Bullet Study]]
!The Denver Bullet Study offers one approach to integrating facts and values in a controversial real-world problem, drawing facts from a set of experts, gauging the values of different stakeholders, and bringing these together for a final decision.
|-
![[13.2 Deliberative Polling]]
!Another approach to getting groups of people to come together to make decisions, in a process where the integration of facts and values is scaffolded.
|-
![[14.1 Scenario Planning|14.1 Scenario Planning]]
!A third approach to integrating facts and values under conditions of uncertainty about what the future will be like.
|-
![[14.2 Wrap Up|14.2 Wrap Up]]
!An overview and conclusion of the course.
|} -->
<!-- == List of Lesson Plans ==


{{Lesson list}}
{{Expand|Topic Summaries|
{{14 week course}}
}}
{{Expand|Concepts Covered|
{{Project topics}}
}} -->
== How to Read a Lesson Plan ==
== How to Read a Lesson Plan ==


There are five parts to each lesson plan.
{{Help:Lesson plan parts}}
# [[#The Lesson in Context]]
== How to Read Discussion Slides ==
# [[#Takeaways]]
# [[#Useful Resources]]
# [[#Recommended Outline]]
# [[#Lesson Content]]
 
=== The Lesson in Context ===
 
This section explains how this lesson fits into the bigger picture of the course. It contains expandable sections with its connection to earlier and later lessons.
 
=== Takeaways ===
{{Work in progress}}
=== Useful Resources ===
{{Work in progress}}
=== Recommended Outline ===
{{Work in progress}}
=== Lesson Content ===
{{Work in progress}}
<!-- == Anatomy of a Lesson Plan ==
 
{{Work in progress}}
 
Each lesson plan has the following components:
# [[#Useful Links|Useful Links]]
# [[#Readings and Assignments|Readings and Assignments]]
# [[#Learning Goals|Learning Goals]]
# [[#Context|Context]]
# [[#Recommended Outline|Recommended Outline]]
# [[#Lesson Content|Lesson Content]]
# [[#Overflow|Overflow]] (this section may sometimes be missing)
 
=== Useful Links ===
 
This section contains links to the prerecorded lecture videos (called "PlayPosits") that the students watch prior to discussion sections (called "labscussions"), the slides to use during labscussion, a "three column" overview of the week, and a link to Boxthe "website page". There may also be other links to handouts, videos, activities, papers, or other things relevant to the lesson.
 
==== Three Column Overview of the Week ====
 
This is a bullet point summary of everything in the PlayPosit videos, labscussion sections, and plenary session for the week. It's mainly intended for faculty to get a sense of what's being taught, but it may be helpful to others as well.
 
==== Lesson Slides ====
 
{{BoxCaution|See the section on the [[#Anatomy of Labscussion Slides|anatomy of labscussion slides]] for more info.}}
These are the slides for this lesson. For most lessons you can use these slides directly as is. For a handful of lessons there will be different versions of the slides for each section. In those cases, separate links for each section will be made available. If you make any changes to the lesson slides, please duplicate the slides and leave them in the same Google Drive folder with your section number(s) in parentheses at the end of the name. This format is important for record keeping purposes.
 
A student-viewable version of the lesson slides will be linked in the syllabus ''after'' each lesson as many of the activities rely on the students being unaware of certain elements of them.
 
==== Website Page ====
 
You should generally '''ignoreBox''' the website page link. It's kept for historical reasons.
 
{{BoxCaution|This website contains out of date content and may not necessarily align with the versions of the lessons presented on this wiki. The wiki is the most up to date version of the content. However, the Information Box on the website may still be a useful reference if you want a slightly different perspective on the material.}}
=== Readings and Assignments ===
 
This section has links to relevant readings and videos that can be assigned to students. In most cases, this also includes a supplemental lecture video presented by one or more professors that have previously taught the course. In the UC Berkeley version of the course, the students watch these videos prior to section.
 
=== Learning Goals ===
 
This is what we intend the students to take away from the lesson. The learning goals begin with the abstract ideas we want to walk away with followed by any specific definitions we would like the students to learn. These learning goals will be made available to the students and are included in the slides for every lesson. This is the content that is in scope for the quizzes and final exam.
 
This section also has "examples" and "common misconceptions" the the students often have or end up with. Not all the examples come up within the lessons normally. Nevertheless, you are welcome to use them. You are welcome to add any other examples you stumble upon or misconceptions you find your students falling victim to.
 
=== Context ===
 
This section contains general information about how this lesson fits into the broader picture of the course as well as which other lessons tie into it.
 
=== Recommended Outline ===
 
This includes any steps that the instructors or students need to take prior to labscussion section as well as any wrap-up that needs to be done after. The "during class" part of this section has recommended minute-by-minute timelines so that you get through the content. Feel free to adjust this timeline to fit the needs of your section.
 
=== Lesson Content ===
 
This is the actual meat of the lesson. It has detailed explanations for each activity in the order that they're done in labscussion.
{{BoxTip|Anything in a blue box is a useful note or tip for the instructor.}}
{{BoxCaution|Anything in an orange box is a warning or note of caution for the instructor.}}
{{BoxAnswer|Anything in a green box or written in text {{Correct|like this}} is the answer or a sample answer to a question.}}
=== Overflow ===
 
This section contains activities and discussions that are '''not''' currently being used but that we want to maintain a record of regardless. Many of them were used in previous iterations of the course. -->
 
[[Category:Reference]]
 
== Anatomy of Labscussion Slides ==
 
The slides for each labscussion are color coded. The "gold-blue" slides represent the "introduction" slides and typically have content you can quickly brush through.
 
<center>
<li style="display: inline-block; vertical-align: top;">
[[File:Activity 0 Slide.png|thumb]] </li>
</center>
 
The remaining slides cycle through "red", "blue", and "green" slides. These always progress in the same order. A change in color corresponds is a visual cue that shows the labscussion is moving on to a new activity. All the slides for the same activity are of the same color. The colors keep cycling if there are more than three activities in a lesson. The section's agenda is also shown whenever there's a transition to a new activity.
 
<center>
<ul style="margin: 0;">
<li style="display: inline-block; vertical-align: top;">
[[File:Activity 1 Slide.png|thumb]] </li>
<li style="display: inline-block; vertical-align: top;">
[[File:Activity 2 Slide.png|thumb]] </li>
<li style="display: inline-block; vertical-align: top;">
[[File:Activity 3 Slide.png|thumb]] </li>
</ul>
</center>
 
=== Introductions ===


Every slide deck begins with a title card that introduces the lesson. Followed by the lesson's agenda, learning goals, and definitions. Note that the lessons are (typically) '''not''' designed to have much time for review at the start. So, you don't have to spend time going over the learning goals and definitions in each section. They're mainly included so that you can flip back to them during class if it comes up and so that the students can reference them easily after class.
{{Help:Discussion slide parts}}
{{NavCard|prev=Assembling your team|next=1.1 Introduction and When Is Science Relevant}}
{{NavCard|prev=Assembling your team|next=1.1 Introduction and When Is Science Relevant}}
[[Category:Reference]]
[[Category:Reference]]

Latest revision as of 15:45, 11 October 2023

Clicking on the topics takes you to the lesson plans. These are listed in the order that they're typically taught. A high-level conceptual organization scheme for these lessons can be found on the concept groupings page. For more on how to shape these into your schedule see the page on designing your schedule.

1.1 Introduction and When Is Science Relevant When is science relevant? The many uses of a scientific approach.
1.2 Shared Reality and Modeling Science is grounded in belief in a common, shared reality with some degree of regularity.
2.1 Senses and Instrumentation Science uses both our direct senses and a variety of instruments to extend our ability to observe phenomena. We trust our instruments for the same reasons we trust our senses; interactive exploration and comparison.
2.2 Systematic and Statistical Uncertainty This topic explores the sources of error and uncertainty in data.
3.1 Probabilistic Reasoning Using meta-judgments of the likelihood that your best judgment is right—how confident you are—enables decisions that take uncertainty into account.
3.2 Calibration of Credence Levels It is important to check the calibration of credence levels; that is, how good one's judgments are about how likely each of one's claims is to be right.
4.1 Signal and Noise The challenges of finding the information we want amidst messy data.
4.2 Finding Patterns in Random Noise We often find mistake noise for signal; how do we minimize these mistakes, given that they are not always easy to tell apart?
5.1 False Positives and Negatives Considering the relative costs of each possible mistake helps us make better decisions under conditions of uncertainty, when we cannot eliminate the possibility of a mistake either way.
5.2 Scientific Optimism The psychological trick of believing one will make progress long enough to enable solving difficult problems.
6.1 Correlation and Causation An introduction to the scientific approach to determining causal relationships.
6.2 Hill's Criteria Building on Correlation and Causation, we examine how to collect evidence for causality in more difficult cases.
7.1 Causation, Blame, and Policy Distinguishing singular causation ([math]\displaystyle{ A }[/math] caused [math]\displaystyle{ B }[/math]) from general causation ([math]\displaystyle{ X }[/math] tends to cause [math]\displaystyle{ Y }[/math]).
7.2 Emergent Phenomena Many phenomena in science are emergent, i.e., visible only at higher levels of organization. This tends to occur when large numbers of elements interact, e.g. as in individuals on social media.
8.1 Orders of Understanding Because each event and/or phenomenon has many causal factors, it is often important to distinguish which factors affect it the most and which factors play a smaller role.
8.2 Fermi Problems Estimating quantities based on what we know.
9.1 Heuristics Some of the heuristics biases that make our probability judgments go awry.
9.2 Biases Some of the psychological biases that make our probability judgments go awry.
10.1 Confirmation Bias Our tendency to preserve our existing or preferred beliefs, even against the evidence.
10.2 Blinding Blind analysis, the practice of deciding how we will analyze data before finding out if the analysis we have chosen supports our hypothesis, counteracts confirmation bias.
11.1 Pathological Science How to catch bad science.
11.2 When Is Science Suspect The capacity for science to be misused to reinforce existing power structures.
12.1 Wisdom of Crowds and Herd Thinking Explore ways that groups fall short of their optimal reasoning ability. There are better and worse ways to aggregate a group's knowledge.
12.2 Grill the Guest Confront a working scientist about their work using course concepts.
13.1 Denver Bullet Study The Denver Bullet Study offers one approach to integrating facts and values in a controversial real-world problem, drawing facts from a set of experts, gauging the values of different stakeholders, and bringing these together for a final decision.
13.2 Deliberative Polling Another approach to getting groups of people to come together to make decisions, in a process where the integration of facts and values is scaffolded.
14.1 Scenario Planning A third approach to integrating facts and values under conditions of uncertainty about what the future will be like.
14.2 Wrap Up An overview and conclusion of the course.

How to Read a Lesson Plan

There are five parts to each lesson plan.

  1. The Lesson in Context
  2. Takeaways
  3. Useful Resources
  4. Recommended Outline
  5. Lesson Content

The Lesson in Context

Each lesson plan begins with a short summary of how it fits into the bigger picture of the course. The summary is followed by expandable sections detailing its relation to earlier and later lessons.

Takeaways

This part of the lesson plan lists target learning goals for the students, definitions that are used in both the lecture and discussion section, examples demonstrating the topic at hand, and several misconceptions that the lesson is designed to address.

Note that these misconceptions are not necessarily ones that students are left with after the lesson. Rather, these are the misconceptions that the lesson is designed in response to in the first place.

Useful Resources

Every lesson plan has an embedded example lecture video, a set of slides that can be used for the discussion section, readings and assignments to give students for homework prior to lesson, and a "handouts and activities" section. This last item has links to any worksheets or other material that's relevant for the discussion section's activities.

Recommended Outline

This section gives an overall schedule for each discussion section as well as any steps that need to be taken before or after each class. This section may note resources you need to gather for each lesson. You can see a full list of these on the inventory page.

Lesson Content

The last section of each lesson has detailed instructions for how to implement the discussion section. This includes minute-by-minute timings, instructions for each activity, answers to each discussion question, and much more. A useful key for reading this is included below.

Answer

Boxes of this color note the answer to some question. In the case of multiple choice questions, the correct answer may instead be highlighted in a small green box.

Tip

Anything in a box of this color is some useful tip that may help with implementing the lesson.

Caution

Boxes of this color provide notes of cation or things to watch out for while teaching the lesson.

Warning

These boxes give you high-level warnings about important implementation details that significantly affect how you plan and run the lesson.

How to Read Discussion Slides

The slides for each labscussion are color coded. The "gold-blue" slides represent the "introduction" slides and typically have content you can quickly brush through.

  • The remaining slides cycle through "red", "blue", and "green" slides. These always progress in the same order. A change in color corresponds is a visual cue that shows the labscussion is moving on to a new activity. All the slides for the same activity are of the same color. The colors keep cycling if there are more than three activities in a lesson. The section's agenda is also shown whenever there's a transition to a new activity.

    Introductions

    Every slide deck begins with a title card that introduces the lesson. Followed by the lesson's agenda, learning goals, and definitions. Note that the lessons are (typically) not designed to have much time for review at the start. So, you don't have to spend time going over the learning goals and definitions in each section. They're mainly included so that you can flip back to them during class if it comes up and so that the students can reference them easily after class.